The Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes


Many people struggle to find the best mascara for sensitive eyes because their sensitive eye area is so specific. For example, some people have super sensitive lids, where even an eyelash curler hurts like crazy! This is unfortunate because most of us love a good cat eye or winged look that usually requires a fair bit of mascara application. There are also those who struggle with sensitive lower lashes that are more prone to getting irritated by mascaras, especially waterproof ones. But fear not because this post will serve as your one-stop guide to finding the perfect formula you can use every day without hurting your eyes. Let’s dive right in!

What is the Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes?

When we talk about the best mascara for sensitive eyes, we’re really looking for the best formula that people with sensitive eyes can use. In this guide, we’ll be exploring which formulas are best for sensitive eyes and how to apply them without hurting your eyes. Waterproof formulas – While you may love the dramatic lashes that a black, waterproof mascara gives you, it may not be the best choice for you if you have super sensitive eyes. Waterproof formulas are thicker in consistency, which makes them harder to rinse off completely. This can clog your pores and cause irritation, not to mention you may have a tough time getting it off at the end of the day. Starter formulas – If you have fairly sensitive eyes, a lighter formula like a brown non-waterproof mascara might be the best choice for you. When applied in moderation and cleaned off correctly, a lighter mascara formula shouldn’t result in irritated eyes.

Why Are Your Eyes So Sensitive?

There are a handful of reasons why your eyes may be more sensitive than the average person’s. Let’s explore a few below!

Allergies – If you’re allergic to certain ingredients, they might be causing your eyes to be sensitive. The most common allergens are soy, dairy, and gluten. However, certain synthetic ingredients have been known to cause irritation as well.

Hormones – If you’ve recently gotten pregnant or are going through menopause, your hormones may be causing some extra eye sensitivity. It’s a great idea to check in with your OBGYN to see if there are any changes you can make to help soothe your eyes.

Age – As we age, our eyes become more and more sensitive to things that don’t bother us in our younger years. This happens for a number of reasons, but is typically due to the fact that our skin becomes less pliable with age and less hydrated.

3 Mascaras to Try If You Have Sensitive Eyes

When it comes to the best mascara for sensitive eyes, there are a few options. Which one you try will depend on your specific eye sensitivity. Let’s explore a few below!

Clinique Lash Power Feathering Mascara – This is a great option for those who have sensitive lids. Lash Power Feathering Mascara is a lightweight formula that won’t weigh down your eyes and cause irritation. When you’re ready to remove it, Clinique suggests using warm water and a gentle makeup remover.

L’Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara – This is a great option for those with sensitive lower lashes. Lash Paradise is a lightweight formula that is super gentle on the lower lash line. L’Oréal also recommends using warm water and a gentle makeup remover when cleaning this one off.

RMS Beauty Un-Cover-Up Concealer – If your eyes are super sensitive and don’t react well to mascara, you can use a concealer to give yourself a little extra oomph. RMS Beauty’s Un-Cover-Up Concealer is a great option for sensitive eyes because it’s very lightweight and doesn’t require you to put any additional pressure on your eyes.

The Catch: Not All Brands are Created Equally

As we mentioned earlier, not all brands of mascara are created equally. Just because you used to use a certain brand and loved it doesn’t mean you’re going to be able to use the same formula again. It’s important to check in with your eye doctor to see if they recommend any specific brands you should try. You can also try asking other women who have sensitive eyes what they use and see if any of them have positive feedback.

2 Tips to Help Soothe Irritated Eyes While Applying Mascara

When you’re getting ready to apply your mascara and you notice your eyes getting red and irritated, there are a few things you can do.

Warm up your lashes – First of all, if you’re using a heated eyelash curler, make sure you warm up the curler with a blow dryer before applying it to your lashes. This helps your lashes more pliable, which in turn will cause less irritation when you curl them.

Use a gentle makeup remover – When it comes time to remove your mascara, try using a gentle makeup remover. You don’t want to use a harsh cleanser that may irritate your eyes further.


Now that we’ve talked about the best mascara for sensitive eyes, you should be able to find a formula that works best for you! Keep in mind that the best mascara for sensitive eyes isn’t necessarily the most expensive mascara. A great formula can come in a variety of price points depending on the brand. When you find the best mascara for sensitive eyes, you can rock your lashes, beaming with confidence!

Related posts